--° Loading... Locating...
Official portrait of Mary Peltola

Mary Peltola Tops 50% in Alaska’s Senate Count. Her Campaign Says Sullivan Has ‘No Mathematical Path’

Democrat Mary Peltola reached 50.1% of first-choice votes in Alaska's Senate race after Saturday's count, enough to win without ranked choice if it holds. Sen. Dan Sullivan hasn't conceded, and counting ends Nov. 18.

Center

Key Points

  • Peltola had 50.1% of first-choice votes to Sen. Dan Sullivan's 46.1% after Saturday's count, per the Anchorage Daily News.
  • Friday night she led by 10,412 votes with fewer than 12,000 ballots left; Sullivan would have needed about 93% of them to tie.
  • NBC News projects Peltola likely to win; AP had not called the race, and Sullivan has not conceded.
  • Counting ends Nov. 18, when ranked-choice tabulation would start if needed; certification is targeted for Nov. 25.
  • Nearly 30% of voters who ranked the other candidate, Dan J. Sullivan, first picked Peltola second, versus about 16% for the senator.
  • A DOJ suit to block certification was dismissed; the 9th Circuit appeal runs past Jan. 11.
Listen to our news podcast

Mary Peltola is now over 50% in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race. After about 4,000 more ballots were counted Saturday, the Democrat had 50.1% of first-choice votes to Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan’s 46.1%, the Anchorage Daily News reported. If she stays above 50% when counting ends, she wins outright and Alaska never has to run its ranked-choice tabulation.

Her campaign isn’t waiting. It said Friday night that there is “no mathematical path for Sullivan to win this race,” the Juneau Independent reported. NBC News’ Decision Desk projected Saturday that Peltola is likely to win. The Associated Press hadn’t called the race as of its latest count, and Sullivan hasn’t conceded. His spokesperson, Nate Adams, told the New York Times on Friday night: “we’re still waiting for every ballot to be counted. And we’ll see what happens from there.”

Can Sullivan still win the Alaska Senate race?

Here’s the math as of Friday night, the last count with full vote totals. Peltola led by 10,412 votes, 138,240 to 127,828, with fewer than 12,000 ballots left to count, according to the Juneau Independent and AP’s count. Even if every one of those ballots went to one of the two leaders and nobody else, Sullivan would have needed about 93% of them just to tie. In a race where he’s been getting about 46%, that isn’t a realistic path. Saturday’s batch moved Peltola further ahead, not closer.

Advertisement article banner article banner

Counting has to wrap up by Wednesday, Nov. 18. That’s also the day ranked-choice tabulation would start, according to the Division of Elections, if nobody has a majority. The state’s target date to certify the result is Nov. 25.

Official portrait of Sen. Dan Sullivan of Alaska
Sen. Dan Sullivan, the Republican incumbent. Photo: United States Senate, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

What if it goes to ranked-choice voting?

It probably wouldn’t save Sullivan either. In ranked choice, the last-place candidates drop out and their voters’ second picks get handed out. The two who would drop are Gerald Heikes, at about 2.1%, and a second candidate named Dan J. Sullivan, at about 1.7%.

That second Sullivan is the strange part of this race. He’s a different man from Petersburg whose name sat on the same ballot as the senator’s. Republicans say he was put there to confuse voters. The New York Times reported that Democratic Senate campaign staff and Peltola’s staff helped recruit him and Heikes. Peltola and Dan J. Sullivan deny it. You’d assume his voters meant to pick the senator. The data says otherwise. Of 4,055 voters who ranked Dan J. Sullivan first, nearly 30% picked Peltola second and about 16% picked the senator, according to an Anchorage Daily News analysis of preliminary ballot data.

What happened to Trump’s lawsuit over the other Dan Sullivan?

It’s been tossed, and the appeal is slow. The Justice Department, at President Trump’s direction, sued to stop Alaska from certifying the race if the senator narrowly lost, and to set aside ballots cast for Dan J. Sullivan. U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed it two days before Election Day. The government appealed, but the 9th Circuit set a schedule that runs to Jan. 11, after new senators are sworn in, the Anchorage Daily News reported. The suit’s own theory also doesn’t fit the numbers anymore: it was aimed at a loss smaller than Dan J. Sullivan’s vote share, and Peltola’s lead is now more than twice that.

On Election Day, Sen. Sullivan called the ballot setup “the biggest cheating scandal in Alaskan history” on CNN. Gov. Mike Dunleavy has ordered a state criminal investigation and the FBI is also looking into it, though neither has said what law may have been broken. A Peltola win would add another seat to the Democratic majority that took shape when Scott Colom beat Cindy Hyde-Smith in Mississippi, and it lands as Trump keeps claiming the midterms weren’t honest.

NBC News: Democrat Mary Peltola likely to win Alaska Senate race.

The BeezLoop Take

The two-Sullivans ballot was a cynical stunt, if the Times reporting holds, and Democrats shouldn’t pretend otherwise. But it didn’t decide this race. Peltola is beating both Sullivans combined, and the voters who picked the other Sullivan leaned her way on their second choice. That’s hard to call confusion.

The bigger worry is the playbook around it: a federal lawsuit filed to block certification before a single vote was counted, plus criminal probes nobody can tie to a specific law. If the result is clear, Alaska should certify on Nov. 25 and the investigations should say what they’re investigating.

The open question: if Peltola finishes above 50%, does Sullivan concede before certification, or does the White House keep pushing a case its own numbers no longer support?

Sources: Alaska Division of Elections · Alaska Division of Elections, live results · Juneau Independent · Anchorage Daily News, Saturday count · Anchorage Daily News, ranked-choice data · NBC News (video)

How We Sourced This

Written by Kevin Nordi

Kevin Nordi is a freelance writer with five years of experience covering politics, sports, and the everyday moments that shape people's lives. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Multimedia…

More from this author →

BeezLoop News is an independent online news, discussion, opinion, and blog publication. Our articles combine reporting with editorial commentary and analysis. See our editorial standards for how we handle sourcing and corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Start typing to search

🔔

Stay Updated!

Get instant notifications for breaking news and important stories. We'll keep you informed!

Don't miss a story

Get the day's clearest news explainers in your inbox.