New York City won’t close Rikers Island on time. Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a plan Friday to shut the jail complex by 2032, five years after the August 2027 deadline set by city law, the AP reported. “It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said. “We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers.”
The plan admits what most people at City Hall already knew: the four borough jails meant to replace Rikers aren’t close to ready. The first one won’t open until 2029.
When will Rikers Island close under Mamdani’s plan?
By the end of 2032. The new jails open in this order, according to City Hall:
- Brooklyn: 2029
- Bronx and Queens: 2031
- Manhattan: 2032
- Plus: a handful of medical facilities for people who need hospital-level or psychiatric care
The city closed one Rikers facility earlier this year. The rest of the complex is still open.
Can the new jails hold everyone now on Rikers?
Not today, and that’s the heart of the plan. Rikers holds more than 6,500 people. CBS New York reported about 6,700 were in custody in June. The four new jails are designed to hold about 4,100. The city’s own target is to get the jail population down to around 4,500. Even if it hits that goal, it would still be a few hundred people over the new jails’ design capacity, a gap neither the city’s announcement nor the news coverage so far explains.
To shrink the population, the city plans to:
- Spend $50 million on job training, education, mental health counseling and drug treatment, and $76 million on community programs and supervision for people awaiting trial, per CBS New York.
- Expand diversion and supervised release, so fewer people sit in jail before trial.
- Restore online bail payment, so people whose families can pay don’t wait days to get out.
- Cut court delays. Mamdani’s office says Rikers detainees are held nearly four times longer than the national average.
- Move most women out of jail beds and into community programs.
“We do not want any New Yorker to spend a day longer in detention than necessary,” Mamdani said. Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards, who was once held at Rikers himself, said, “At Rikers, out of sight, out of mind is the norm for both people in our custody and our staff.”
Why has closing Rikers taken so long?
The City Council voted to close it in 2019. Since then, the borough jail plan has met pushback, including from a mayor who didn’t want it. Former Mayor Eric Adams opposed both the borough jails and federal oversight. A federal judge, citing “abnormal and unacceptable” conditions, appointed an outside manager to run the jails. Mamdani’s office says assaults at Rikers happen at eight times the rate of similar jails.
Mamdani has made Rikers part of a wider shake-up of the city’s public safety system. This month he disbanded the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group, and earlier he replaced four members of the police watchdog board.
The BeezLoop Take
Give the plan credit for honesty about the date. Every mayor since 2019 has let New Yorkers believe 2027 was real, and it wasn’t. A 2032 date tied to specific jail openings is at least something people can hold City Hall to.
But the math has to work. A plan that depends on cutting the jail population by about 2,000 people, while building jails that hold fewer than its own target, leaves little room for error. If crime ticks up or judges set more bail, what happens to the closing date then?
Sources: NBC News / AP · CBS New York · CBS New York (video)






