--° Loading... Locating...
ICE officers making an arrest

Video Shows ICE Agents Taking Down a Pregnant U.S. Citizen in Modesto. She Was Released Without Charges

Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, a pregnant U.S. citizen, says ICE agents pepper-sprayed her and threw her to the ground as she filmed an arrest outside the Stanislaus County Jail on Sunday. She was released without charges. ICE accused her of assault, which she denies.

Center

Key Points

  • Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, a pregnant U.S. citizen, was taken down by ICE agents in Modesto, Calif., on Sunday.
  • Video shows an agent firing pepper spray toward her and two agents cuffing her face-down.
  • Her husband is heard shouting, "She's pregnant with child."
  • She was held for several hours and released without charges; a hospital found the baby unharmed.
  • ICE accused her of assaulting an agent, which she denies.
  • DHS did not respond to ABC News's request for comment.
Listen to our news podcast

A pregnant U.S. citizen says immigration agents pepper-sprayed her and threw her to the ground in Modesto, California, while she was filming an arrest outside the Stanislaus County Jail on Sunday. Video shows Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, being taken down and handcuffed face-down as her husband shouts, “She’s pregnant with child,” ABC News reported.

She was held for several hours at an ICE facility and released without charges, her attorney says. A hospital checked her and found the baby unharmed.

ICE officers making an arrest
ICE officers make an arrest. This is a file photo, not the Modesto incident. Photo: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

What happened in Modesto?

According to her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, Vargas Andrade was with her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, and her sister-in-law, Monica Alvarado, watching federal agents. She’s part of a local group that monitors ICE activity around Modesto. Agents blocked her sister-in-law’s car, forced their way in, said she was transporting strangers, and detained a man inside.

Advertisement article banner article banner

The video, shot by her husband, shows agents moving to arrest Vargas Andrade as she pulls away. An agent fires pepper spray toward her, though the video doesn’t show where it hit. Seconds later two agents put her on the ground and cuff her. She says she told the agents she was pregnant.

ABC News: Pregnant woman says ICE pepper-sprayed her and threw her to the ground.

What does ICE say?

ICE accused her of assaulting one of the agents, according to her attorney. She denies it, and she hasn’t been charged with any crime. The Department of Homeland Security didn’t respond to ABC News’s request for comment.

Can you legally film ICE agents?

Generally, yes. In public places, people have a First Amendment right to record law enforcement doing their jobs, as long as they don’t physically interfere. Courts have backed that right repeatedly. That’s why monitoring groups like the one Vargas Andrade belongs to film arrests, and why the line between recording and interfering keeps ending up in disputes like this one. Courts have pushed back on other aggressive tactics too, like when a judge stopped DHS agents from knocking on doors to hunt for noncitizen voters.

The BeezLoop Take

Whatever happened in the seconds before that video started, pepper-spraying and slamming a pregnant woman to the ground for filming an arrest needs a public explanation. If she assaulted an agent, charge her and show the evidence. If not, the agents involved should answer for the force they used.

DHS saying nothing isn’t good enough. Agencies that want public trust can’t go silent every time a video like this spreads.

The open question: will DHS release its own footage or reports, or will the only record be the video her husband shot?

Sources: ABC News · ABC News (video)

How We Sourced This

Written by Kevin Nordi

Kevin Nordi is a freelance writer with five years of experience covering politics, sports, and the everyday moments that shape people's lives. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Multimedia…

More from this author →

BeezLoop News is an independent online news, discussion, opinion, and blog publication. Our articles combine reporting with editorial commentary and analysis. See our editorial standards for how we handle sourcing and corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Start typing to search

🔔

Stay Updated!

Get instant notifications for breaking news and important stories. We'll keep you informed!

Don't miss a story

Get the day's clearest news explainers in your inbox.