The Justice Department gave up its court fight over Alaska’s Senate race Thursday, two days after Democrat Mary Peltola won it outright. In a 19-page filing with the 9th Circuit, the department said the case is moot and asked the court to wipe out the lower-court ruling that went against it, MS NOW reported.
The filing comes with an unusual admission. “The United States therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means” of figuring out whether votes cast for a second candidate named Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. were meant for the incumbent, Sen. Dan Sullivan.
Why did the DOJ drop the Alaska Senate lawsuit?
Because the math made it pointless. The government’s theory was that a lesser-known candidate with nearly the same name as Sen. Sullivan was pulling votes that belonged to the senator. But Peltola won more than 50% of the vote, enough to win without Alaska’s ranked-choice tallies, and she beat Sen. Sullivan by more than 12,000 votes. The other Daniel J. Sullivan got fewer than 5,000. Even if every one of those votes went to the senator, he’d still lose.
U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason had already thrown the case out on Nov. 1. She ruled the government hadn’t shown a court could fix its claimed injury and warned that digging into individual ballots would violate voters’ right to a secret ballot. The department appealed the same day. Now it wants the 9th Circuit to erase her ruling instead of leaving it on the books. It also asked the court to reject requests from voting rights groups for sanctions.

Is the criminal investigation into the Peltola campaign over?
No. Attorney General Todd Blanche says the criminal investigation into the second Sullivan’s candidacy is still going, Newsweek reported. It’s looking at whether Democrats recruited him to split the senator’s vote. On Election Day, prosecutors sent target letters to several people, including Marc Elias, whose firm represents Peltola’s campaign. Elias accused the department of “targeting me and my law firm on Election Day.”
No one has been charged, and it’s not clear that recruiting a candidate with a similar name breaks any law. Peltola denies any role. President Trump has demanded she be prosecuted and said of the investigation, “I’m the one that said ‘do it.'” A separate state probe ordered by Gov. Mike Dunleavy is also open. “The Alaska Bureau of Investigation continues to investigate allegations related to the Alaska US Senate election,” said Austin McDaniel of the state Department of Public Safety.
When does Peltola take office?
- Nov. 25: the state’s target date to certify the results.
- Nov. 30: the last day to ask for a recount.
- Dec. 5: the last day to challenge the result in state superior court.
- Jan. 3, 2027: Peltola would be sworn in.
Sen. Sullivan hasn’t conceded. His campaign has said it will let the process play out until every legal vote is counted and certified. Peltola’s message after the race was called was short: “Thank you, Alaska. Let’s get to work.” Her win was the first Democratic Senate victory in Alaska in 18 years.
The BeezLoop Take
The lawsuit asked a court to sort ballots by what voters secretly meant, which is exactly what a secret ballot is supposed to prevent. The judge said so, the voters made the question moot, and now the department wants her ruling erased so it can’t be cited next time.
The criminal probe is the part to watch. A president publicly ordered an investigation of a rival campaign, and no one has been charged with a crime anyone can name. If nothing comes of it, will anyone answer for the target letters sent on Election Day?
Sources: MS NOW · Newsweek · MS NOW (video)






