--° Loading... Locating...
Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen

Trump, Xi and Putin Agree a Nuclear War ‘Cannot Be Won’ in First Three-Way Meeting, but Set No Limits or Dates

In their first three-way meeting, Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin declared a nuclear war "cannot be won and must not be fought" and agreed to a dialogue on nuclear risks. They discussed Ukraine and Iran but announced no deals, limits or dates.

Center

Key Points

  • Trump, Xi and Putin met for about 90 minutes in Shenzhen on Nov. 19, their first three-way meeting.
  • Their declaration says a nuclear war "cannot be won and must not be fought."
  • They agreed to a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks, with no dates or venue.
  • They also backed more refined fuel supply and UN reform, and criticized the ICC.
  • Ukraine and the Middle East were discussed, but no deals were announced.
  • Trump: the three are "uniquely positioned" to reduce nuclear weapons.
Listen to our news podcast

President Trump, China’s Xi Jinping and Russia’s Vladimir Putin met together for the first time Thursday in Shenzhen, China, and came out agreeing on one big principle: “a nuclear war cannot be won and must not be fought,” according to a joint declaration released by Chinese state media, France 24 reported. They also agreed to hold a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. There were no numbers, no treaty and no dates.

The meeting ran about an hour and a half, CNBC reported, after a working lunch between Trump and Xi. Trump then boarded Air Force One for Washington.

Trump, Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin at their trilateral meeting in Shenzhen
Trump, Xi and Putin at their three-way meeting at the APEC summit in Shenzhen. Photo: President of Russia, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What did Trump, Xi and Putin agree to?

  • Nuclear war: all three reaffirmed it “cannot be won and must not be fought.”
  • Nuclear talks: they’ll “engage in dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing nuclear proliferation.” No timeline was given.
  • Oil: they plan to increase production and supply of refined petroleum products, a nod to fuel prices squeezed by the Iran war.
  • Institutions: they backed UN reform and said the International Criminal Court and similar bodies “must not abuse their jurisdiction.”

“As the world’s three largest nuclear powers by far, the United States, Russia and China are uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on earth,” Trump said. “We are really making history.” Xi called the talks “positive, constructive, and fruitful,” and Putin said the discussion “took place in a completely open atmosphere.”

Advertisement article banner article banner
Associated Press: Trump, Xi and Putin hold three-way talks on nuclear arms and wars in Ukraine and Iran.

Did they talk about Ukraine and Iran?

Yes, though the White House had said beforehand that Ukraine wasn’t on the agenda. Trump said they’d discuss the war, and Putin said Trump seemed committed to ending it. Putin added that talking about European security “is pointless without the Europeans” and invited European officials to Moscow. On Iran, Trump said the goal includes “not letting Iran have nuclear weapons.” Chinese state media said only that the “situation in the Middle East” came up. No deal was announced on either war.

Does this make nuclear war less likely?

Not by itself. The “cannot be won” line echoes a statement Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev made in 1985, and the five permanent members of the UN Security Council said the same in 2022. Words like these matter as a floor, but they don’t cut a single warhead. What would matter is the dialogue they promised turning into actual limits, especially with China, which has never agreed to any limits on the size of its nuclear arsenal.

The BeezLoop Take

Getting the three biggest nuclear powers in one room was worth doing, and agreeing to talk about nuclear risk is better than not talking. But the declaration’s other lines, like warning the International Criminal Court off leaders, read more like a list of shared complaints than a peace plan.

Watch what happens next, not what was said in Shenzhen. A date and a venue for nuclear talks would be real progress. Another photo op wouldn’t.

The open question: does the promised nuclear dialogue ever meet, or does Thursday join the long list of summit statements nobody follows up on?

Sources: CNBC · France 24 live updates · Associated Press (video)

How We Sourced This

Written by Kevin Nordi

Kevin Nordi is a freelance writer with five years of experience covering politics, sports, and the everyday moments that shape people's lives. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Multimedia…

More from this author →

BeezLoop News is an independent online news, discussion, opinion, and blog publication. Our articles combine reporting with editorial commentary and analysis. See our editorial standards for how we handle sourcing and corrections.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Start typing to search

🔔

Stay Updated!

Get instant notifications for breaking news and important stories. We'll keep you informed!

Don't miss a story

Get the day's clearest news explainers in your inbox.